In 2017, just as the First Trump administration was setting its ominous course, Steve Bannon, then the president’s chief strategist, professed his admiration for the book The Fourth Turning, written two decades earlier by amateur historians William Strauss and Neil Howe. While many critics targeted the book’s deterministic approach as a theoretical flaw, many others embraced the way the authors laid out the rhythms of the four seasons to define and explain the political cycles of American history as it has been dictated by major events.
Based on the book, many contend that we are now in winter, the fourth turning, which began in 2008 with the Great Recession, This cycle should climax and reset within the next few years and certainly sometime within the first half of the 2030s. In 2017, journalist Jeremy W. Peters summarized Bannon’s penchant for this theory, by explaining, “The Fourth Turning will trigger a political upheaval beyond anything Americans could today imagine. New civic authority will have to take root, quickly and firmly — which won’t be easy if the discredited rules and rituals of the old regime remain fully in place. We should shed and simplify the federal government in advance of the Crisis by cutting back sharply on its size and scope but without imperiling its core infrastructure.”
A decade later, with this president in the middle of his disastrous second term, we have seen what happens when the leader’s mindset is cast in the “with-us-or-against-us” approach.

In its latest production, the consistently adventurous Voodoo Theatre Company puts us in the heart of that earlier period, in the summer of 2017. The occasion is an alumni reunion for an ultra-conservative Catholic school in Wyoming. Steeped in a politically intellectual milieu not often found in contemporary theater, Will Arbery’s 2019 play Heroes of the Fourth Turning is given a vigorous rendering in a well-conceived production. Credit to the company for not diluting the tenor of the rhetoric, which definitely will make a good number of theatergoers squirm uncomfortably throughout the two-hour performance.
Arbery’s script emerges from the experiences of his upbringing in Dallas that coincided with the Bush political era and was infused with the white, Catholic, rightwing politics common to the period and setting.
Directed by Jack Cobabe, the production bristles with excellent performances from the five actors. This play, which was a 2020 Pulitzer Prize finalist in the drama category, is not pleasant entertainment by any measure. As Cobabe wrote in a program note, “This play is not about one side being right. Far from it actually. Rather, it’s an honest conversation between people discussing their beliefs and allowing them to change. This honest discussion has been lost from our political stages as well as our day-to-day lives. Going forward if you’re met with someone or something you do not understand or agree with, engage with it, do not retreat. Only through honest discussion and listening. Can we find common ground and find the path forward together.”

Cobabe’s creative brief is achieved here. There are no liberal voices as a counterpoint. The play opens in August 2017, days after the violent Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia and the weekend before the Great American Eclipse. Incidentally, Wyoming was one of a dozen lucky states where the eclipse was viewed in its totality. Four alumni of a small conservative Catholic liberal arts college have returned for a homecoming. Also, one of their former beloved teachers has just been named the college’s new president.
It becomes evident early in the play that each character’s acute internal pain eclipses the opportunity to celebrate what should have been a joyful moment for fellowship and congratulations to a mentor whom they respected during their student days. One would expect them to be thrilled about a presidential administration that vindicates the ultraconservative values of their education. Yet everyone feels incomplete and whatever personal satisfaction they sense feels strangely hollow.
This is a tall emotional order for the cast. The actors rise impressively to the challenge. Audiences are very likely to rebuff the temptation to connect to characters who hold political views they find utterly repugnant. Likewise, the actors would agree with the audience on that point. But the performances demonstrate convincingly how well the actors have embodied these characters and generally care for the emotional contours each carries in the stage narrative.

In the opening, Alvaro Cortez confidently establishes the tone and rhythm asked for in Arbery’s script. He portrays Justin, a former U.S. Marine and expert marksman who works at the college. Solitude is his preferred escape, as he contemplates joining a Catholic monastery. Brimming with a big city attitude, Emily Tatum skillfully represents the Fourth Turning dynamism as Teresa, a New York City political writer who channels the ideals that Bannon brought when he worked in Trump’s first term. Justin and Teresa are strong-willed, ideologically and physically. Their self-righteousness is unfettered, but the emotional foundations of their faith and political bearings reveal steadily widening cracks.
On the other hand, the characters of Kevin and Emily embody physical shortcomings in their respective manifestations of pain. Nat Vaughn’s portrayal of Kevin elucidates vividly a young man who uses alcohol as his emotional palliative to obscure his deep troubles which force him to question whether or not his faith and sociopolitical identity are as genuine as he was taught to believe.
As Emily, Charlotte Gordon effectively balances the critical fulcrum in this character ensemble. The daughter of Gina, the new college president (played with equally convincing credibility by Barb Gandy), Emily emerges as the compassionate yet conflicted moderate in the ensemble. Beset by chronic pain syndrome, Gordon channels the complex of physical, spiritual and emotional trials, not unlike those of individuals in history who eventually were canonized as saints in the Roman Catholic Church.

This Voodoo Theatre Company production does not ask audiences to empathize with these characters. The actors wisely chose not to render these characters as caricatures. Every one of them carried vulnerabilities they have tried to conceal as best as they could. It was notable that some audience members periodically resorted to laughter as their defense mechanism during some of the most vulnerable scenes.
It is a subtle reminder that especially now as the political movement these characters celebrate in this play is unraveling at an accelerating pace, we should not rush to gloat about their shortcomings and failures. Honestly, none (or very few) of us are benign creatures when it comes to holding strong our political convictions. Yet the actors do so well with Arbery’s script that audience members surprisingly find themselves caring as much about characters who struggle mightily with emotional and spiritual turmoil and pain as do the actors on stage.
For the actors to achieve this sense of impartiality in their rendering is quite the achievement and something that Voodoo Theatre Company has managed to exemplify in other productions as well.
The run continues through Oct. 25 in the Studio 5400 Theatre in the Mid-Valley Performing Arts Center in Taylorsville. For tickets and more information, see the Voodoo Theatre Company website.
